8 महिन्यांपूर्वी
11 महिन्यांपूर्वी
11 महिन्यांपूर्वी
टिप्पण्या
Preston Britton 9 तासांपूर्वी
The quarrelsome daffodil interestingly pour because himalayan analytically answer athwart a elite goose. slim, ancient silica
Devansh 9 तासांपूर्वी
It has just been 1 minute in the video but I want to share that I have watched a STOL video of a tail dragger aircraft which was able to takeoff in about 6 ft of ground roll due to "HIGH HEAD WINDS".
Uagaduguanac YT 9 तासांपूर्वी
No,because of no airspeed...
Zharesss 9 तासांपूर्वी
But what if the engines are not running but the conveyor belt moves at take off speed?
John Lement 9 तासांपूर्वी
Captian Joe Marketing!!
sreelakshmi ellur 9 तासांपूर्वी
Captain Joe Did u run out of topics to make video on? Why such a simple topic, even an 8th grader can answer that.
NYAGA WESLEY MUNENE 9 तासांपूर्वी
I WOULD LIKE TO UY IT BUT I CANT I DONT KNOW HOW
Wesleyng Wei Lik 10 तासांपूर्वी
Physics and logic (Zero Net Force)
shep 10 तासांपूर्वी
Its a shame this needs answering 😂
Leo Toikka 10 तासांपूर्वी
Gotta love Kennedy Steve, what a legend!
Ron_the_Skeptic 10 तासांपूर्वी
Of course the plane can take off. The wheels are free spinning when the brakes are released. Propulsion is via the engines moving air and lift is via air moving past the wings.
Adam Valle 10 तासांपूर्वी
Ok but for the first part, if the wheels being matched exactly prevents the plane from developing forward momentum, how is it that the wheels ever even began spinning? Since the scenario is impossible because it deals with infinity, let’s assume the wheels have zero friction. The plane will take off with the wheel speed accelerating to infinity. With even the tiniest amount of friction, the wheels would melt.
HCL Channel 10 तासांपूर्वी
what if the conveyor runs at the same time as the plane so the ground speed is faster than run only with engine So if conveyor 150 knots and the plane just runs at 120 knots so the ground speed is 270 knots right .
Tim Simulations 10 तासांपूर्वी
No, the plane won't takeoff.
The Cease 10 तासांपूर्वी
The second part blew my mind 👌🏾. I’m glad we never got examined before on this 😃
Jay Dee 10 तासांपूर्वी
Four words.. No airflow, no lift
Duane Suter 10 तासांपूर्वी
Awesome job with the bone marrow donation Joe! Much respect!
cory calloway 10 तासांपूर्वी
The judicious smoke cranially sprout because swing separately belong but a tenuous alley. spotty, secret grandson
Oferb553 10 तासांपूर्वी
This riddle was actually tested by mithbusters, with a small aircraft (i think was a cessna 150 or a piper) taking iff a convayer belt. It took off with no problem.
Muthu Kumar 10 तासांपूर्वी
We can compare this topic with ourselves on a treadmill. While running on a road, we can feel the airflow around us. But while running on a treadmill, we can't feel that airflow circulation around us. So my opinion will be the plane won't take off.
Simon Rancourt 10 तासांपूर्वी
Seriously ? Those who proposed this know NOTHING about aviation.
Richy Chen 10 तासांपूर्वी
I think it will take off
Michael Karnerfors 10 तासांपूर्वी
Here is where the riddle falls apart: Speed of the wheels in relation to _what_ ? Speed of the belt in relation to _what_ ? Wheels in relation to the ground and (top of belt) in relation to the ground? Okey, easy peasy: the plane moves at _v_ , the belt moves at _- v_ and the wheels move in relation to the belt at _2v_ . Wheels in relation to the ground, belt in relation to the wheels? Even easier: belt remains stationary the whole time. Wheels in relation to the belt, belt in relation to wheels? Super-easy: belt moves the wheels, the wheels do not spin at all. Wheels in relation to the belt, belt in relation to the ground? That is a paradox. That is trying to prove that -1 = 1.
Orange Bridge 10 तासांपूर्वी
The wheels are moving but the plane isn’t so There is no airspeed so the plane can’t takeoff
Kristina 10 तासांपूर्वी
No. The wheels turning don't supply lift for the wings.
khem 10 तासांपूर्वी
Nice
Quist Science Station 10 तासांपूर्वी
Of course, the plane can't take off, the speed of the conveyor belt is the same as the wheels, and when they come into contact, they apply the same force on each other. Thrust (PLANE) and Drag (CONVEYOR BELT) counteract each other. But when thrust is in more action, the plane can move along. But these 2 forces are the same, generating no detectable motion. (JUST SAYING AND EXPLAINING WHAT I THINK). And I didn't watch the full video when typing this.
Samantha Willmer 11 तासांपूर्वी
for me the best looking planrs are the boeing 777 concordand the b 2 bombet
Julian Holtorff 11 तासांपूर्वी
I would guess no. The airplane needs to speed up to generate any lift. As soon as the airplane starts to roll, the conveyor belt starts to move the plane in the other direction. So the actual movement of the plane is zero. The engines could run as powerful as they can but it all results in zero movements, therefor no lift and no takeoff. Thats my guess.....
Kounelas 11 तासांपूर्वी
*before Joe explaining: I think the plane will not takeoff as the wings are the ones that make a plane fly. The wheels may for sure spin, but the plane will not takeoff as all it needs is air passing over it’s wings at a certain speed, which in a normal takeoff will be identical to the wheel’s speed. If you were to put the plane on a car or truck accelerating as the 747 would, without the wheels spinning at all, the plane would takeoff. That’s how some seaplanes takeoff on land. Btw I’m a 15 year old super into aviation and wishing to become a pilot!
Cedric Cappelle 11 तासांपूर्वी
Obviously it can't take off! You need to move relative to the air, not the surface!
Aphex Twin 11 तासांपूर्वी
If you were to attach the plane to something on the ground, eg, a jet bridge, and start the conveyer belt, the wheels would start rotating but the plane obviously wouldn’t move. Now detach the plane, because of a small amount of friction in the wheel bearings the plane would start moving backwards slowly. Add a little bit of engine thrust to compensate for that. Then slowly increase the speed of the conveyer belt and the thrust of the engine and again the plane wouldn’t move and thus don’t generate any lift. In reality, the conveyer belt and the engines would create some airflow around the wings that will create some lift. But before that could become really relevant the conveyer belt and the wheels would start to self-destruct.
QBOX 83 11 तासांपूर्वी
obviously no, aitplane needs air under the wings
Val SGI 11 तासांपूर्वी
I say No.
Val SGI 11 तासांपूर्वी
Why : Because in this situation the plane cannot have any air speed => no lift => no take off. (I answer when the questions are asked) (I'm french so sorry for my approximate English)
AD P 11 तासांपूर्वी
This is so funny LOL :-) Next time use a huge fan. Would like to see that one instead.
njcurmudgeon 11 तासांपूर्वी
While not airline-specific, this reminds me of another transportation industry - the railroads. Where I live in New Jersey, in the pre-Covid days when taking a train into Manhattan was a more frequent occurrence, there was a conductor on the line I took who had all kinds of tattoos. He was perfectly fine at his job, but he did get some interesting looks from some passengers. But obviously New Jersey Transit did not have an anti-tat hiring policy. Of course, given how they pay less than other area railroads and have had staff-retention issues (trains delayed because they couldn't find an engineer!) so long as you have a pulse you're a good candidate...
John Svensk 11 तासांपूर्वी
Yes it will move forward and take off! But only due to thrust from the engines... The conveyor belt's velocity is completely irrelevant, since the wheels are not powered!
Xavier Romagosa 11 तासांपूर्वी
Soak the tires with oil. Apply full brakes. Full thrust. Take off.
Sourav Pramanik 11 तासांपूर्वी
Nope, it's not gonna happen, as there will be less lift generated on the wings during that time.
T33K3SS3LCH3N 11 तासांपूर्वी
The plane would accelerate even without wheels, just very painfully. The conveyor belt can't actually push the plane backwards, the wheel and belt will just match their rotations while the plane accelerates anyway.
Grumm HD 11 तासांपूर्वी
It can
jaco Fourie 11 तासांपूर्वी
No because the wings need pressure
Grumm HD 11 तासांपूर्वी
Sorry, but your answer is misleading. The real reason is the friction of the belt which matches the thrust and thus makes the plane stand still. Additionally you just accelerate the tires. This is independent from the friction force applied to the tire and coincidentally matches the momentum used to turn the tire. (Due to the rolling condition of tires)
Zeta Darus 11 तासांपूर्वी
Commenting when i'm at 1:00 in the video, no I don't think the plane can take off, since the plane isn't moving the airspeed is zero, so the wings don't generate lift (assuming there's no front wind) the engines would just produce thrust to keep the plane in the center of the conveyor belt, without any lift I'm curious though, if the engines were in front / behind the wings, would it move enough air to possibly give the plane enough lift to take off without moving?
Dania Awni 11 तासांपूर्वी
maybe if the breaks are on the plane would take off..? i don't know if the breaks can handle it though
Chandra Prasad 11 तासांपूर्वी
How will the aircraft create lift for the wings?
Kevin Ling 11 तासांपूर्वी
question: will a plane take off on a runway with extremely low surface friction?
Chippermonkey33 11 तासांपूर्वी
Yes. There was a show in the US called Mythbusters that tested this, and proved that it will be able to take off.
Ashwin G 12 तासांपूर्वी
No. Just because the wheels move as fast as takeoff speed the wings won't have air to generate lift
TechPorkChop 12 तासांपूर्वी
Can the same principles of an aircraft carrier slingshot system be applied to airport runways for commercial aircraft?
Bilel Maadi 12 तासांपूर्वी
Even if the plane reach 300kn there will be ni lift on the wings
Csmok 12 तासांपूर्वी
planes takeoff with airspeed under wings which generates lift not wheels' speed
runner007 12 तासांपूर्वी
Again safe with a single sensor without redundancy? Yeah Boeing concept of $afety saving.
golong 1 12 तासांपूर्वी
A-fos-trof
UpperLipProductions 12 तासांपूर्वी
mrpost.info/down/vhi-i/kbGFqaKXprKbtJI
UpperLipProductions 12 तासांपूर्वी
Myth busters already tackled this, the plane takes off
Chris Hard 12 तासांपूर्वी
I love this question. Basically it is, if physics could be whatever you want it to be, what would happen? The answer is whatever you want. You’d probably set the engines for takeoff and the universe would end.
ruppokemon25 12 तासांपूर्वी
Why is this man a pilot? This man needs to be a teacher
Priyantha Thrikawala Waduge 12 तासांपूर्वी
Next time the riddle is how do you taxi with the conveyor belt
Thomas Gabrielsen 12 तासांपूर्वी
You have the courage to conclude on a puzzle that even physics don''t want dare (or bother) to answer. Ballsy! Even Randall at XKCD decided to write a blog post about it instead of making a comic: blog.xkcd.com/2008/09/09/the-goddamn-airplane-on-the-goddamn-treadmill Even after watching your video I have no idea what would happen, and I'm not going to argue about it either. :-)
Ondřej Stejskal 12 तासांपूर्वी
well, technically, if there is extreme headwind (like slightly above take-off speed of 747), it could take-off (it will basicaly be like VTOL B747)
Talha Abhi 12 तासांपूर्वी
Yes
Bertrand Giron 12 तासांपूर्वी
Hi ! Liked this episode and I have a question : as far as I can remember, we didn't experience water salute landing at Boston Logan, May 2018, although it was the inaugural flight Paris CDG/Boston by Norwegian. I'm convinced it's impossible to miss from the cabin, even though we landed at dusk. Thanks for your videos, I love them !!
Art Houston 12 तासांपूर्वी
I think you are forgetting some things. Maybe over-thinking this a bit. Because we are used to seeing planes rolling, we are deceived by the riddle, thinking that the plane will dutifully stay in one place due to the wheels spinning. The lift is generated by the movement of the plane through the air, not over a stationary runway. The wheels and the conveyor belt are irrelevant, as long as the wheels are theoretically intact. The thrust produced by the engines propel the airframe into the air mass, and the runway is merely supporting the plane as it produces this thrust.The key idea is that the airplane wheels do not determine forward motion, as with a car. Further, there can be no instantaneous speed matching, since that implies an infinite speed. Thrust will certainly generate forward motion, and therefore, the wheel speed goes through a range of zero to infinite. A moving conveyor belt does not keep the plane in one place, either. If the conveyor speed matches wheel speed, no drag is imposed on the airframe by the conveyor. In theory, you could have the wheels and the conveyor move to mach speeds, (or a theoretical infinite speed) and the wheel assembly would break apart, but the thrust produced by the engines would indeed continue to move the plane through the air mass, and if the wheel assembly was still intact at rotation, it would take off. This so-called riddle is founded on limited thinking.
ToyotaGR 12 तासांपूर्वी
There is a way to make it fly way sooner as travel distance on a runway! If you make the belt, like the rubber straight escalators wich means, When a plane stops on the runaway to take off, you make the rubber strip move itself by electric motors like escalators, Wich means, if you make it go at for example, 300 km/h the wings will have enough air lift, since the plane would be moving at 300 km/h min plus the air thrust around 400 km/h relative to the ground, But covering allot less distance relative to the ground
Joshua Hall a.k.a. Controlla 12 तासांपूर्वी
Great video Captain Joe.☺️
MrBenTheBear 12 तासांपूर्वी
The tested it on Mythbusters. The plane takes off.
Chris P 12 तासांपूर्वी
What if the plane was a VTOL F35? 🤔😉
Aviation World 12 तासांपूर्वी
Next Question : Why some planes fly over Antarctica while most won't
Aabhas Tandon 12 तासांपूर्वी
the plane will be unable to take off, due to zero lift being produced by the wing
andy5478 12 तासांपूर्वी
The plane flys... period. The mythbusters even tested this. So long as the wheels turn freely it flys.
Jatin Kale 13 तासांपूर्वी
It won't! The plane will be stationary and no lift on the wings!
Michael Goldner 13 तासांपूर्वी
Photons do not move sideways. The right model to explain this effect is the wave model.
pete bateman 13 तासांपूर्वी
Waste of time. No matter how carefully you explain this some people almost wilfully misunderstand it.
Jonathan De Souza 13 तासांपूर्वी
8:05 That is so logical 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ephraim Mathapo 13 तासांपूर्वी
Fly safe Joe.
Jens Pedersen 13 तासांपूर्वी
No, having the conveyer-belt turning excatly the same speed as the wheels will define the aircraft to completely stand still, compared to the sorroundings. (otherwise, the definition is untrue). This means no airflow for the wings (except wind - but that's not part of the riddle).
Kilian Corish 13 तासांपूर्वी
No you can't. You have ti make lift
Thimblebumble 13 तासांपूर्वी
Disregarding fuel use, it should be able to take off? That large of a conveyor belt, moving fast enough to have the force transmitted through the bearings into the plane, would also accelerate the air over the runway to a ridiculous extent
Ryan Chon 13 तासांपूर्वी
You are very handsome!
Ruslan Zarifov 13 तासांपूर्वी
It won't lift off, because the air around the plane isn't moving, therefore the plane won't have a lifting force.
AlecByte 13 तासांपूर्वी
Well no, idiots. The plane will only take off if it has lift from the wind! And making the plane stay on the ground isn't going to work. Example: Let's say the conveyor is moving a 120kts. And the plane is also putting thrust and idling at 120kts. So now the plane is staying still. It will NOT take off. Why? Because there's nothing to lift that aircraft! Conclusion: The plane will not fly because there is no lift being generated from the wings. Sometimes I wonder how these people think of these incredibly stupid ideas.
andy5478 12 तासांपूर्वी
You are incorrect. The plane engines pull it through the air. The wheels are there only to prevent the fuselages from contacting the ground. So long as the wheels can turn freely at speeds approaching infinity then it will fly. If the wheels can't turn freely then that may be a factor to keeping it on the ground but that isn't part of this theoretical exercise.